To Be Completed


I find showing in-progress photos especially important with EIT Diaries; the project has assumed a weight that only action and execution – no matter how flawed – can break. So in that spirit I thought I’d share Second Thoughts, the story of. . .

Well, maybe I’ll leave that up to you.
Second Thoughts - In Progress
The Flickr description has more on the photo: problems with its execution, potential causes, and my reactions to it. It’s considered de rigeur to present a photo to the viewer with no explanation – the image to stand self-contained; we’re left to respond ourselves, to draw our conclusions alone, the photographer’s own thoughts, response and reactions irrelevant.

Isn’t that limiting?

I understand the rationale – you, as the viewer, can judge the work outside the structure (confines ?) imagined by the artist – but I’ve never felt comfortable with it. Better to present the photographer’s background, motivations, and hopes for the photo as another data point – not the definitive reading of the piece, but a potential one. You can disagree with their interpretation, bring your own one; you can say: “I understand what he was going for – but he didn’t convince me“; you can be left cold. But at the very least you raise the discussion beyond “I like it” or, “I didn’t like it.”

Flickr photo page

Add comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.